Description
The average city driver spends 6-14 minutes looking for a parking place, and in large cities, the time increases to 18-20 minutes. It is estimated that this time spent searching for a parking lot represents 30% of congestion on city streets. A Smart Parking System makes use of sensors or other technologies to determine the availability of parking lots in cities. This information can be shared with drivers, reducing the time spent looking for parking and thus reducing traffic congestion. Moreover, smart parking can be used to improve the usability of the parking place itself.
Parking fees are already part of the cities’ revenues. Implementing a Smart Parking System enables cities to control their traffic better, apply different tariffs according to different areas and hours, and use per-minute rates - instead of flat rates - thanks to new billing models.
(Shoup, 2007; Shoup, 2008; IBM, 2011)
Smart Parking systems and their functions can have several effects that can support the aims of the municipality or the users. The following diagram shows how the different aspects are intertwined.
Essential benefits of Smart Parking (Anke, Scholle, 2016, translated)
Problems to be solved?
Bad air quality | Congestion | Underused parking space | Park offenders | Accidents/ collisions |
Cost Structure
Costs differ a lot depending on the variant and number of equipped parking lots. As a reference, a trial package by T-systems with 15 sensors operates for two years and API interface and consultation for the installation costs are €8,998.
(T-Systems International GmbH, 2020)
Another cost example shows how much money has to be spent for a robotic parking system (Automated Parking). Here an automated parking system can even reduce costs, because more parking lots can be produced and commercialised in the same area.
Comparison of costs for a conventional garage and a robotic parking system (Robotic Parking, 2020)
Aside from the implementation and maintenance costs, there are also cost benefits through a potential cost reduction and a potential revenue increase.
Results of some Smart Parking installations (Anke & Scholle, 2016)
Financial potentials of Smart Parking (EY, 2017)
City Context
What supporting factors and characteristics of a city is this Solution fit for? What factors would ease implementation?
Costs depend on number of parking lots, type of parking, existing infrastructure for traffic, etc.
Supporting Factors
- Already existing traffic guidance system lower the costs and helps to successfully implement the new smart parking module into the overall traffic system.
- No big infrastructural development is required, as sensors and cameras can be installed into the current city infrastructure.
- A stable internet connection is required for sending and receiving information.
Government Initiatives
What efforts and policies are local/national public administrations undertaking to help further and support this Solution?
Cities like Barcelona, Birmingham, Braunschweig and Manchester have implemented pilot projects for smart parking. As shown in the table, the smart parking projects had recognizable positive effects in many cities.
Results of Sensor implementation in different cities (Anke, Scholle, 2016, translated)
Research has shown that there can be a reduction of 240g CO2 and 231 mg NOx per parking lot search.
(T-Systems International GmbH, 2019)
Stakeholder Mapping
Which stakeholders need to be considered (and how) regarding the planning and implementation of this Solution?
Stakeholder Mapping (BABLE, 2021)
Market Potential
How big is the potential market for this Solution? Are there EU goals supporting the implementation? How has the market developed over time and more recently?
The market for Smart Parking is still in development. Many new companies are founded and new products are launched. The size of the global market is predicted to grow from $1.9 billion to $3.8 billion.
Size of global smart parking market in 2018 and 2023 in billion USD (statista, IoT Analytics, 2018)
Smart Parking offers various benefits for citizens as well as for the operator and the municipality. Depending on the details of the solution implemented, the main benefits can vary. The following graphic shows the operation of a Smart Parking System, including the matching benefits the solution offers.
Smart Parking process
- Decreased Congestion: As free parking spots can be found easily, the need to drive around in a city to find a parking lot is obviated and the traffic congestion decreases.
- Time-savings and less stress: Citizens can save time as they are guided to a free parking spot straight away, which also reduces the level of stress when driving in cities.
- Flexible pricing models: Due to exact monitoring of occupancy of parking spots, prices can be adapted easily. On average, current implementations show that this leads to decreased prices and increased utilisation of paid parking spots. Overall, this also leads to an increased revenue for the operator.
- Increased personal efficiency: As all parking spots are monitored in a Smart Parking System, there is less need for patrols and the capture-rate still increases.
(Shoup, 2007; Shoup, 2008; IBM, 2011)
Legal Requirements
Relevant legal directives at the EU and national levels.
There is no European regulation regarding smart parking, as it is usually the city's responsibility to regulate parking. For example, some cities like Zurich and Hamburg have limited the number of parking spaces in the city centre. Therefore, if a new parking place is built off-street, an on-street place should be eliminated. Cities also have regulations regarding parking time, tariffs, parking zones and user restrictions (Residents, disabled, etc.).
(ITDP, 2011)
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679: General Data Protection Regulation
(EUR-Lex, 2021)
The creation of this solution has been supported by EU funding
Use Cases
Explore real-life examples of implementations of this Solution.
Accessible Parking: Using Satellite Data to Map Accessible Assets
Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council and ENABLE, through the Smart Sandyford Programme, have partnered with Access Earth to prototype a ground-breaking, satellite classifier tool to map accessible assets within a built environment.
Smart Parking in Ettelbrück (LX)
In order to reduce the 'cruising' time of its citizens, the City of Ettelbruck deployed a technology which enables real-time monitoring and visualisation of the available parking spaces in the city.
Real-Time Mobility 360° – Barcelona
While the city of Barcelona offers an array of options for optimizing urban mobility, these solutions are scattered across multiple applications. This fragmentation prevents residents from having a centralized and comprehensive overview of real-time mobility solutions.
Intelligent parking system (Impulse VLCi)
It provides real-time information on the status of parking spaces for people with reduced mobility, loading and unloading areas and cab rank areas. It is expected to be the origin of the total sensorization of these spaces in the city.
Mobility Station in Mülheim
The Mobility stations in Mülheim provide commuters and residents of the busy district with a location, where they can easily find various alternative transport options. The aim is to encourage behavioral change from using cars towards more active modes of transport like walking and cycling.
Parking Management System
With the vision of transforming the parking policy from normative numbers, a more demand driven optimum solution was developed using ICT technologies to improve the user experience. The system is aimed at increasing the occupancy of parking lots.
Green Parking Index in Combination with EV Car Sharing Pool
The Green Parking Index in Stockholm is designed to encourage alternative forms of transport, thus reducing the demand for the private parking places which must be provided when building new and renovating old housing in Stockholm.
Shared E-Mobility System in Milan
Milan’s shared e-mobility system includes: e-cars, e-bikes, e-logistics vehicles, smart parking, e-vehicle charging, and condominium e-car sharing.
Smart taxi stand system in Barcelona
The Smart Taxi Pilot in the city of Barcelona makes it possilbe to provide taxi drivers and taxi clients with real time information about taxi availability at each taxi stand through a mobile app.
Digital Parking Management: ParkingSpotter
MHP is testing its self-developed ParkingSpotter as part of the Living Lab innovation network in Ludwigsburg. The aim of the pilot project is to reduce the amount of traffic in the cul-de-sac, thus reducing the risk to pedestrians, reducing exhaust fumes and saving time for drivers.
Adaptive parking management based on energy efficiency and occupancy
The Municipality of Madrid designed a smart parking management scheme, including giving priority to HOVs and clean vehicles, and specific parking regulations to encourage good and sustainable urban delivery operations.
Smart and Flexible Parking Using New Technology
The city of Stockholm is piloting two semi-automatic systems for on-street parking surveillance.
Digital Parking Services in Warsaw and Gdansk, Poland
The main goal of the Digital Parking project is to make unused parking capacity available to the NaviPay application users. Our Digital Parking lots in Warsaw and Gdansk provide drivers and application users with innovative, fully-digital experiences, making parking more seamless and convenient.
Smart Tourist Bus Parking in Wroclaw, Poland
NaviParking aims to facilitate work in the tourism sector, streamlining the movement of tourist buses, and reducing time lost for parking space search. By limiting unnecessary traffic, the solution improves traffic flow in the city for the benefit of drivers, residents, and tourists in Wroclaw.
Smart Parking in Aachen
A pilot project, installing 13 sensors to generate a digital twin of the city with live data, to reduce parking problems.
Demand Management - Transport
There are three Air Quality Management Areas (AQMAs) of which the city centre is of most concern due to a higher number of pollution exceedances. A Strategic Car Parking Review was undertaken during 2017 and 2018 which essentially formed a baseline of car parking in the city centre.
The City of Tequila Gears up for a Smart Future
Culture, heritage, and a unique national drink. The Mexican town of Tequila has already captured the world’s attention. But now it’s about to become famous for a completely different reason: the town is going digital. By 2040, it doesn’t just want to be a smart town, it wants to be a Smart City.
Supporting New Mobility and reducing parked cars in the streets of Schwabing West, Munich
Mobility behaviour in densely populated cities needs a change towards a higher use of New Mobility. By presenting the full range of alternative mobility, this pilot project in Munich helped residents to change their daily mobility usage.
Want to see our expert's advice about this solution?
Log in